Old-Fashioned Butter Mints – Easy Homemade Christmas Candy

Old-Fashioned Butter Mints are a nostalgic homemade candy that practically melts in your mouth. With their creamy texture, delicate peppermint flavor, and pretty red-and-white swirls, these little sweets are perfect for Christmas celebrations, weddings, baby showers, and holiday gift boxes. Best of all, they’re surprisingly easy to make with just a handful of simple ingredients and no cooking required.

If you remember those soft, meltaway mints served at weddings and special occasions, this recipe will bring back wonderful memories. Instead of buying them at the store, you can prepare your own batch right in your kitchen. The combination of butter, powdered sugar, heavy cream, and peppermint extract creates a smooth, sweet candy dough that’s easy to shape and customize.

These Old-Fashioned Butter Mints are also a fun holiday project because you can make them in different colors, experiment with flavors, and create beautiful candy pieces to share with family and friends. Whether you’re preparing a Christmas dessert tray or looking for a simple edible gift, these homemade mints are a lovely choice.

Why You’ll Love These Homemade Butter Mints

There are plenty of reasons to add this easy candy recipe to your collection. It’s simple enough for beginners but produces beautiful little treats that look like they came from a traditional candy shop.

• No cooking required: There’s no need for a candy thermometer, stovetop, or oven. Simply mix, shape, cut, and allow the mints to dry.
• Only a few ingredients: Butter, powdered sugar, heavy cream, peppermint extract, and food coloring are all you need.
• Delicious meltaway texture: These candies are soft, creamy, and smooth, gradually dissolving in your mouth.
• Perfect for Christmas: The red-and-white candy cane appearance makes them especially festive.
• Easy to customize: Change the colors, flavors, and shapes to suit different celebrations.
• Great for gifting: Package them in small jars, decorative tins, or cellophane bags for homemade holiday presents.

Unlike traditional hard peppermint candies, these butter mints have a delicate texture and a rich buttery sweetness that makes them especially enjoyable.

Ingredients You’ll Need

One of the best things about Old-Fashioned Butter Mints is that the ingredient list is short and straightforward. Each ingredient contributes to the smooth consistency and classic peppermint flavor.

• Butter: The foundation of the recipe. It gives the mints their rich, creamy taste and helps create a smooth candy dough. Softened butter is essential for easy mixing.
• Powdered sugar: Also called confectioners’ sugar, this provides sweetness and structure. It helps transform the butter and cream into a firm, workable dough.
• Heavy whipping cream: Adds moisture and creates a softer, smoother texture. It also helps bring the ingredients together.
• Peppermint extract: Gives the candies their refreshing mint flavor. Start with a small amount and adjust according to your taste preference.
• Red gel food coloring: Creates the beautiful red-and-white stripes that resemble traditional candy canes. Gel coloring is particularly useful because it adds vibrant color without introducing too much liquid.

Ingredient Substitutions and Alternatives

You can easily adapt these homemade peppermint candies if you want to try something different.

• Salted or unsalted butter: Both work well. Salted butter adds a slight contrast to the sweetness, while unsalted butter provides a more neutral buttery flavor.
• Milk instead of heavy cream: Regular milk can replace the cream if necessary. Add it gradually because too much liquid can make the dough sticky.
• Almond extract: A wonderful alternative for traditional wedding-style butter mints.
• Vanilla extract: Creates a mild, sweet flavor that works beautifully for everyday occasions.
• Lemon extract: Adds a refreshing citrus flavor, especially when paired with pale yellow food coloring.
• Orange extract: Gives the candies a bright, fruity twist.
• Natural food coloring: You can leave the mints white or use suitable natural coloring if you prefer to avoid conventional food dyes.

When changing extracts, begin with a small quantity and taste the mixture before adding more.

How to Make Old-Fashioned Butter Mints

These homemade butter mints require very little hands-on work. The most important part is getting the dough to the right consistency before shaping it.

Step 1: Prepare Your Work Surface

Start by covering a clean, flat work surface with parchment paper or wax paper. A silicone baking mat also works well.

Keep a little extra powdered sugar nearby. You’ll need it if the dough becomes sticky while you’re shaping the mints.

It’s helpful to place the parchment paper on a baking sheet or tray so you can move the shaped candy ropes without disturbing them.

Step 2: Beat the Butter

Place the softened butter in a large mixing bowl.

Using a hand mixer on low speed, beat the butter until it becomes light, smooth, and fluffy. This step helps create a creamy base for your Old-Fashioned Butter Mints.

Make sure your butter is softened at room temperature rather than melted. Melted butter can make the candy dough difficult to handle.

Step 3: Add the Remaining Ingredients

Add the powdered sugar, heavy whipping cream, and peppermint extract to the bowl.

Begin mixing on low speed to prevent the powdered sugar from flying out of the bowl. Gradually increase the speed as the ingredients start combining.

Continue mixing until everything is incorporated and a thick, firm dough forms.

The dough should be soft enough to roll but firm enough to hold its shape. If it feels too sticky, gradually add more powdered sugar. If it’s too dry or crumbly, add a little cream.

Step 4: Divide and Color the Dough

Transfer the dough to your prepared work surface and divide it into two portions.

Keep approximately three-quarters of the dough white and place the remaining quarter in a separate bowl.

Add a small amount of red gel food coloring to the smaller portion. Knead gently until the color is evenly distributed.

Avoid overworking the dough because excessive kneading can soften it and make the color less defined.

You should now have one larger white portion and one smaller red portion.

Step 5: Roll and Twist the Candy Dough

Take a small amount of white dough and roll it between your hands or on the prepared surface to create a rope.

Repeat with a smaller amount of red dough. Place the red rope alongside the white rope, then gently twist the two together.

The white portion should be noticeably thicker than the red portion to create attractive candy cane-style stripes.

Work with small sections at a time rather than trying to roll the entire batch at once.

Step 6: Shape the Butter Mints

Once the red and white dough is twisted together, gently roll the rope between your palms or on the work surface to smooth it.

Keep the pressure light so the two colors remain distinct.

Continue shaping the remaining dough into twisted ropes. Pinch off any uneven ends and adjust the thickness as needed.

You can make the ropes as thick or thin as you prefer, depending on the size of the finished candies.

Step 7: Cut the Mints Into Small Pieces

Arrange the twisted ropes on your prepared parchment paper and let them sit for approximately one to two hours.

This short resting period allows the outside of the dough to become less sticky, making cutting easier.

Use a sharp knife or pizza cutter to slice the ropes into small, bite-sized pieces.

Try to keep the pieces relatively similar in size so they dry evenly.

Step 8: Let the Candies Dry

Arrange the cut butter mints in a single layer on the parchment paper.

Leave them uncovered at room temperature for approximately 24 hours so they can dry and develop a firmer exterior while maintaining their soft, meltaway centers.

Once completely dry, gently loosen the candies from the parchment paper using a bench scraper or spatula.

Your homemade Old-Fashioned Butter Mints are now ready to enjoy or package for gifting!

Tips for Perfect Old-Fashioned Butter Mints

Although this recipe is simple, a few small details can make a big difference in the finished candies.

Use properly softened butter. Butter that’s too cold won’t blend smoothly, while melted butter can make the dough greasy and difficult to shape.

Add powdered sugar gradually if needed. The dough should be firm and pliable. If it sticks to your fingers or work surface, incorporate a little additional powdered sugar.

Don’t add too much cream. Heavy cream helps create a smooth consistency, but excess liquid can make the dough difficult to roll. Add small amounts only when necessary.

Choose gel food coloring. Gel coloring provides a stronger shade without adding as much moisture as liquid food coloring.

Keep the colors separate until shaping. Work the red and white dough independently before twisting them together. This helps preserve the attractive striped appearance.

Don’t skip the drying time. Allowing the mints to rest for a full 24 hours helps them develop the right texture and makes them easier to store.

Work in small batches. Smaller portions are easier to roll and twist, especially if you’re making a large batch for Christmas.

Fun Ways to Customize Your Butter Mints

One of the most enjoyable things about this recipe is how easy it is to change the colors, shapes, and flavors.

Try Different Flavors

Peppermint is a classic choice, but you don’t have to stop there.

• Almond butter mints: Replace the peppermint extract with almond extract for a traditional wedding candy flavor.
• Vanilla butter mints: Use vanilla extract for a gentle, sweet flavor.
• Lemon butter mints: Add lemon extract and color the dough pale yellow.
• Orange butter mints: Use orange extract for a bright citrus variation.
• Maple butter mints: Add maple flavoring for a warm, sweet taste.
• Cinnamon butter mints: Try cinnamon extract for a delicious alternative during the fall and winter holidays.

Change the Colors and Shapes

You can also make these candies suitable for almost any occasion.

For Christmas, stick with traditional red-and-white stripes or add green for an extra festive appearance.

For Easter, divide the dough into several portions and use pastel pink, yellow, lavender, and green coloring.

For baby showers, create soft pink or blue mints. For weddings, keep them completely white and use almond extract for a classic presentation.

You can even press the candy dough into silicone molds to create hearts, flowers, stars, or other decorative shapes.

What to Serve With Old-Fashioned Butter Mints

These little candies are delicious on their own, but they also make a wonderful addition to dessert tables and holiday celebrations.

Here are a few serving ideas:

• Hot chocolate: Serve a small bowl of peppermint butter mints alongside warm hot cocoa.
• Christmas cookies: Add them to a holiday cookie platter with sugar cookies, chocolate crinkles, and shortbread.
• Holiday candy trays: Combine them with homemade fudge, peppermint bark, chocolate truffles, and peanut brittle.
• Coffee and tea: Their sweet peppermint flavor makes them a lovely after-dinner treat.
• Wedding dessert tables: Arrange white butter mints in decorative bowls for a nostalgic reception favor.
• Party favors: Divide them into small individual bags for birthdays, baby showers, and holiday gatherings.

Their pretty appearance and small size make them especially convenient for sharing.

How to Store Homemade Butter Mints

Proper storage helps maintain the texture and flavor of your homemade candy.

Once the mints have dried completely, transfer them to an airtight container. Keep them in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and excess humidity.

When fully dried and stored properly, they can stay fresh at room temperature for approximately two to three weeks, although their texture may gradually soften.

If you prefer, you can refrigerate them in a sealed container for longer storage. Allow refrigerated mints to return to room temperature before serving for the best texture.

For longer storage, freezing is another option. Arrange the candies in a single layer on a parchment-lined tray until firm, then transfer them to a freezer-safe airtight container. They can be frozen for up to three months. Thaw at room temperature before enjoying.

Avoid stacking freshly made mints before they have dried completely, as they may stick together.

A Sweet Old-Fashioned Treat Worth Sharing

Old-Fashioned Butter Mints are proof that some of the simplest homemade candies can be the most memorable. Their creamy, buttery texture, refreshing peppermint flavor, and pretty red-and-white appearance make them a wonderful addition to Christmas celebrations and special occasions throughout the year.

What makes this recipe especially appealing is how easy it is to customize. You can experiment with different extracts, create colorful designs, or use candy molds to make beautiful little treats for friends and family.

Make a batch for your next holiday gathering, add them to your homemade candy collection, or package them in decorative jars for thoughtful edible gifts. These soft peppermint candies are a nostalgic favorite that’s always worth making again.

Frequently Asked Questions

More Relevant Recipes

• Easy Grinch Poke Cake – A Fun Christmas Dessert
• White Chocolate Peppermint Cheesecake Ball – Easy No-Bake Holiday Dessert
• Easy Cinnamon Hard Candy Recipe for the Holidays

Print